Brow Definer 3-in-1 Pencil

Why you’ll love it: A lot of our editors have made room in their (very crowded) makeup bags to give this brow pencil a permanent spot. And when you try it, you’ll quickly see why: The formula makes brows look naturally thicker and the included spoolie makes blending a breeze. You'll get 1 shade in your box.

How you’ll use it: The slanted tip is great for drawing on hairs: Add the most to your arch, use a slightly lighter hand on the tails, and go easiest on the inner corners. Then brush the spoolie over your brows to shape them while blending.