Why you’ll love it: If you dread removing your mascara at the end of the day, this Athr Beauty formula is for you. The do-it-all mascara lengthens, lifts, and defines lashes while a cocktail of nourishing ingredients (green tea extract and acai oil) care for lashes without smudging, smearing, or melting. And it can be completely removed with warm water—no excessive rubbing, tugging, or mess required.

How you’ll use it: After curling your lashes, hold the wand at the base of your lash line and wiggle it upward from root to tip. Repeat until you reach your desired look. We found that the first coat delivers length and definition, while the second boosts volume (and drama).